[PATCH] pei386, ld auto-import
Charles Wilson
cwilson@ece.gatech.edu
Sun Sep 23 14:51:00 GMT 2001
In this message:
Missing variable 'pe_data_import_dll'
http://sources.redhat.com/ml/binutils/2001-08/msg00186.html
Nick Clifton reported that the recently accepted auto-import changes to
ld on pei386 caused a build problem on other pe platforms that don't
support DLLs (specifically arm-epoc-pe).
This was because the auto-import changes added a reference in pe-dll.c
to a variable in pe.em -- but that variable wasn't defined unless
DLL_SUPPORT was defined.
Now, Nick posted a workaround to the problem here:
http://sources.redhat.com/ml/binutils/2001-08/msg00187.html
but AFAICT it was never applied to CVS. (Plus, it was just a
workaround). In that message, Nick also suggested the following:
I still
feel however, that there ought to be a better way to solve this
problem. My suggestion is that the definition of DLL_SUPPORT ought
to be set in ld/configure.tgt rather than ld/emultemp/pe.em and then
tested in ld/pe-dll.c before it uses variables that are only defined
in pe.em.
That's not what I did, because ld/configure.tgt seems to only set shell
variables, which are later used to control Makefile options. However,
the list of acceptable shell variables is fixed: targ_emul,
targ_extra_emuls, targ_extra_libpath, and targ_extra_ofiles. These are
then (eventually) used by configure to fixup the Makefile.in's when
generating the Makefile's. So, sure, it's *possible* to do what Nick
suggests -- by changing configure.in/configure so that it will replace
@DLL_SUPPORT@, adding a few more rules to Makefile.in, adding
DLL_SUPPORT where appropriate in configure.tgt, etc., but ...
It really doesn't seem right to me that "DLL_SUPPORT" be added to the
list of stuff controlled by configure.tgt, which is currently limited to
things like targ_*. Comments?
So, the attached patch is identical to the one I posted a few days ago,
but the Subject line of that earlier message was probably misleading.
Anyway, the attached patch fixes this problem by:
a) make the offending variable (pe_data_import_dll) static within pe.em
b) add a new function in pe.em (pe_get_data_import_dll_name) which
either returns this variable (#ifdef DLL_SUPPORT), or returns a constant
string (#else). However, at least the function itself is always defined.
Could somebody on arm-epoc-pe or other non-DLL-supporting pe platform
please verify that this patch allows successful compilation/operation of
binutils? the patched version does work on cygwin (but the unpatched
version worked on cygwin, too)
Thanks,
Chuck
More information about the Binutils
mailing list