[v3] basic_string::reserve() shrink-to-fit?

Neil Ferguson nferguso@eso.org
Thu Dec 11 17:47:00 GMT 2003


Nathan Myers wrote:
> On Thu, Dec 11, 2003 at 03:51:36PM +0100, Neil Ferguson wrote:
>> 
>> Initial capacity:       0
>> After 6 char assign:    6
>> After reserve(1000000): 1003491
>> After reserve():        1003491
>> 
>> ie. reserve() doesn't seem to shrink the string capacity to fit.
> 
> I'm afraid that's what's supposed to happen, in basic_string<> and 
> in vector<>.  The idiom for shrinking to fit is to use swap().
> Minimally,
> 
>   std::swap(std::string(str.data(), str.size()), str);
> 
> This might be a good thing to put in the FAQ.
> 
> When this was raised as a Defect Report, the committee recognized 
> it as clunky, but not, technically, a Defect, and thus beyond their 
> charter to change at that time.  For the next standard they have 
> more latitude.
> 
> Nathan Myers
> ncm-nospam@cantrip.org

Could you give me a reference to read, please? My understanding is
that vectors should not shrink via resize(), but that strings can.

I just rechecked my copy of ISO 14882 (admittedly a 1998-09-01 one)
and section 21.3.3, paragraph 11 (on page 391) says that shrinking
and shrinking to fit are permitted for strings, but implementations
are not bound to comply with a request to do so.

Neil.



More information about the Libstdc++ mailing list