Common V3 coding bug

Benjamin Kosnik bkoz@redhat.com
Wed Jul 18 09:59:00 GMT 2001


Thanks Mark.

> I am.  People expect to get the version from their base class--thus the
> broken code in v3, which was written by experts.  I have no objection to a
> flag to turn off such a warning, but I feel strongly that it should be on
> by default.

Me too. 

>From the discussion following Mark's initial posting, this looks like 
something that needs to be explained with some kind of intelligent 
diagnostic message and an error. I suspect the discussion has already 
pointed out the phrasing for the error.

For future reference, I'm in favor of a strict and 
standards-conformant compiler by default so that bugs like this are 
easily found. 

If you keep posting bugs like this Mark, I'm going to have to try your 
branch, sooner rather than later. Please post on this list when you want 
people to bang on it.

;)

Also, let's fix this code up on the trunk. 

Mark, you've already done several patches 
to libstdc++-v3 as you've found broken items (two come to mind, including 
this one.) I know you are working on a branch, but I'm trying to keep the 
trunk the cannonical source for libstdc++-v3: as a courtesy to me and the 
other libstdc++ developers, can you please check in both of these patches 
to the trunk?

Thanks in advance,
benjamin



More information about the Libstdc++ mailing list