[PATCH] powerpc: New feature - HWCAP/HWCAP2 bits in the TCB
Rich Felker
dalias@libc.org
Tue Jun 9 17:42:00 GMT 2015
On Tue, Jun 09, 2015 at 04:48:10PM +0100, Szabolcs Nagy wrote:
> >> if hwcap is useful abi between compiler and libc
> >> then why is this done in a powerpc specific way?
> >
> > Other platform are free use this technique.
>
> i think this is not a sustainable approach for
> compiler abi extensions.
>
> (it means juggling with magic offsets on the order
> of compilers * libcs * targets).
>
> unfortunately accessing the ssp canary is already
> broken this way, i'm not sure what's a better abi,
> but it's probably worth thinking about one before
> the tcb code gets too messy.
For the canary I think it makes sense, even though it's ugly -- the
compiler has to generate a reference in every single function (for
'all' mode, or just most non-trivial functions in 'strong' mode).
That's much different from a feature (hwcap) that should only be used
at init-time and where, even if programmers did abuse it and use it
over and over at runtime, it's only going to be a small constant
overhead in a presumably medium to large sized function, and the cost
is only the need to setup the GOT register and load from the GOT,
anyway.
Rich
More information about the Libc-alpha
mailing list