Please raise version number above RPM releases

Michał Górny mgorny@gentoo.org
Sun Jun 27 06:36:42 GMT 2021


Hello,

We've been packaging the RPM's debugedit executable as 'debugedit'
since 2006.  This means that the versions of debugedit packages
in Gentoo have corresponded to RPM releases.

Now, we'd like to switch to your version.  However, the problem is that
you've restarted versioning -- at least from our perspective.  If we
added debugedit-0.3 to Gentoo today, it would be seen as an older
version that the 'old' debugedit-4.16.1.3 (i.e. rpm's debugedit).

There are hacks around this but they're all particularly ugly.  Hence,
I'm wondering if it wouldn't be too much of a hassle to you to raise
the version number above the current RPM version, i.e. version 5.* or
6.* (if you take rpm5 into consideration, it is pretty dead though).

While I do realize the problem's on our end, it's non-trivial to fix
because of backwards compatibility requirements we have.  And as I said,
workarounds are particularly ugly and confusing, so I'd rather avoid
them if possible.

TIA for your consideration.

-- 
Best regards,
Michał Górny




More information about the Debugedit mailing list