cygsshd fails due to bad ownership or modes of /cygdrive/c/Users

Frank-Ulrich Sommer f-u.s@gmx.net
Wed Feb 7 02:26:12 GMT 2024



On 06.02.2024 22:22, Brian Inglis via Cygwin wrote:
> On 2024-02-05 18:36, Eliot Moss via Cygwin wrote:
>> On 2/5/2024 8:28 PM, Frank-Ulrich Sommer via Cygwin wrote:
>>> On 05.02.2024 00:53, Frank-Ulrich Sommer via Cygwin wrote:
>>>> I'm trying to run cygsshd on my PC with Windows 11 and connect from a linux machine. I have added the public key to /cygdrive/c/Users/xxx/.ssh/authorized_keys and created a symbolic link from  /cygdrive/c/Users/xxx/.ssh to /home/xxx/.ssh. As usual I checked the access rights and mode of the .ssh directory (700 and belongs to user xxx) and the authorized_keys file (600 and also belongs to user xxx) and also of the home directory (had to change ownership).
>
> Change the symlink from Cygwin home to your home, as symlinks have a+rwx perms, so you can not use one for .ssh:
>
>     $ ln -sv `cygpath -aU "C:/Users/$USER"` /home/
>
Currently I'm reluctant to do this as my current cygwin home directory looks quite "clean" and does not contain hundreds of Windows files and subdirectories. I just added the link as the .ssh directory was automatically created as /cygdrive/c/Users/fus/.ssh and I wanted to have an easier access and avoid having two different .ssh directories which showed to be quite risky in the past.
>>>> Now I get the following strange messages:
>>>> [...]
>>>> Feb  5 00:35:50 XXXXX sshd: PID 2798: debug1: temporarily_use_uid: 197609/197121 (e=18/18)
>>>> Feb  5 00:35:50 XXXXX sshd: PID 2798: debug1: trying public key file /home/xxx/.ssh/authorized_keys
>>>> Feb  5 00:35:50 XXXXX sshd: PID 2798: debug1: fd 5 clearing O_NONBLOCK
>>>> Feb  5 00:35:50 XXXXX sshd: PID 2798: Authentication refused: bad ownership or modes for directory /cygdrive/c/Users
>>>> Feb  5 00:35:50 XXXXX sshd: PID 2798: debug1: restore_uid: 18/18
>>>> [...]
>>>> Why is cygsshd complaining about the Windows "Users" directory and not about the directory of user xxx (/cygdrive/c/Users/xxx)? And how can I solve this?
>
>>> Looking at the OpenSSH source code (on Github, not from Cygwin) I found a function "safe_path" that checks that the ownership and access modes for all path components are correct.  This relies on "platform_sys_dir_uid" which checks if a UID may own a system directory. The code checks for UID zero and might also accept an OS specific second value (PLATFORM_SYS_DIR_UID) but for Cygwin this seems not to be set. But I don't know where to find the source code for the exact version that is used in Cygwin and I'm unsure about build settings.
>
> Run Cygwin setup and select package openssh Source checkbox to download the source package, or go to your Cygwin upstream mirror and download the source tarball shown in setup.ini prefixed with your nearest Cygwin mirror site e.g.
>
> https://ftp.fau.de/cygwin/x86_64/release/openssh/openssh-9.6p1-1-src.tar.xz
>
> Build settings are in the Cygwin package build control script definitions file openssh.cygport in the source tarball or build repo:
>
>     https://cygwin.com/cgit/cygwin-packages/openssh/tree/openssh.cygport
>
> ...
>     --disable-strip
>        --with-kerberos5=/usr
>            --libexecdir=/usr/sbin
>            --with-xauth=/usr/bin/xauth
>        --with-libedit
>        --with-security-key-builtin
>
Thanks for that tip, I found and installed it and succeeded to build it with additional info in the error message (see below).
>>> A comment defines this a safe path as follows:
>>> "This is defined as all components of the path to the file must be owned by either the owner of the file or root and no directories must be group or world writable."
>
>>> The "Users" directory is owned by "SYSTEM" (numeric: 18 according to stat) and only writable by Administrators and SYSTEM. The mode cygwin shows for /cygdrive/c/Users is 0750 which should be OK.
>
>>> So my question is: are "Administrators" and "SYSTEM" different users and does cygsshd accept SYSTEM (numeric 18) as a valid user who may own system directories? If the numeric ID is really 18 I can't see how this check can succeed but I'm not sure the code used in Cygwin is the same.
>
>     $ id SYSTEM
>     uid=18(SYSTEM) gid=18(SYSTEM) groups=544(Administrators),18(SYSTEM)
>
OK, I get the same on my system which seems to be Windows standard.
>> Administrators and SYSTEM are not the same.  And neither is exactly equivalent
>> to the concept of root in POSIX.  SYSTEM (in my experience) is used for things
>> like backup tools that needs access to almost every file. Administrators is for
>> system administration.  I don't have deep knowledge of all of this - others can
>> give a deeper / more nuanced answer.
>
> Look at permissions at all levels:
>
> $ lsattr -d ~/.ssh/;echo;ls -dl ~/.ssh/;echo;getfacl ~/.ssh/;\
>                 icacls `cygpath -m ~/.ssh`
> ------------ /home/BWI/.ssh/
>
> drwx------ 1 $USER None 0 Mar  8  2023 /home/$USER/.ssh/
>
> # file: /home/$USER/.ssh/
> # owner: $USER
> # group: None
> user::rwx
> group::---
> other::---
> default:user::rwx
> default:group::---
> default:other::---
>
> .../.ssh/ $HOST\$USER:(F)
>           $HOST\None:(Rc,S,RA)
>           Everyone:(Rc,S,RA)
>           CREATOR OWNER:(OI)(CI)(IO)(F)
>           CREATOR GROUP:(OI)(CI)(IO)(Rc,S,RA)
>           Everyone:(OI)(CI)(IO)(Rc,S,RA)
>
> Successfully processed 1 files; Failed processing 0 files
>
this results in:

/home/fus

$ lsattr -d ~/.ssh/;echo;ls -dl ~/.ssh/;echo;getfacl ~/.ssh/;                icacls `cygpath -m ~/.ssh`
------------ /home/fus/.ssh/

drwx------+ 1 fus fus 0 Feb  4 23:35 /home/fus/.ssh/

# file: /home/fus/.ssh/
# owner: fus
# group: fus
user::rwx
group::---
group:SYSTEM:rw-        #effective:---
group:Administratoren:rw-       #effective:---
mask::---
other::---
default:user::rwx
default:group::---
default:group:SYSTEM:rw-        #effective:---
default:group:Administratoren:rw-       #effective:---
default:mask::---
default:other::---

C:/Users/fus/.ssh/ NT-AUTORITÄT\SYSTEM:(OI)(CI)(DENY)(X)
                    VORDEFINIERT\Administratoren:(OI)(CI)(DENY)(X)
                    NT-AUTORITÄT\SYSTEM:(OI)(CI)(RX,W,DC)
                    XEONE3_1245V6\fus:(F)
                    VORDEFINIERT\Administratoren:(OI)(CI)(RX,W,DC)

1 Dateien erfolgreich verarbeitet, bei 0 Dateien ist ein Verarbeitungsfehler aufgetreten.

> Try:
>
> # add perm query cmds for info before and after changes
> $ chmod -c u+rwx,go-rwx    ~/.ssh/
> $ setfacl -b        ~/.ssh/
> $ chmod -c u+rwx,go-rwx    ~/.ssh/    # same as before
>
> then ls -l ~/.ssh/ and ensure that:
>
> - non-key ssh files    ...        have    u+rw-x,go-rwx     perms,
> - private key files    id_...        have    u+r-wx,go-rwx perms, and
> - public key files    id_*.pub    have    a+r-wx         perms.
>

The problem seems to be that OpenSSH does not even arrive at checking the home diretory or the .ssh directory. It starts checking every directory in the path and fails already at "/cygdrive/c/Users". Now that I know how to get the sources I added debug output to the error message. OpenSSH sees this directory as belonging to user with UID 18 and it has mode 4750. Mode ist checked not to contain 0022 which is fine here. Then it checks that the owner is the correct system user and the only criteria is that the UID must be zero. Only for AIX and HPUX the user "bin" with UID 2 is also accepted. So this check fails and OpenSSH assumes that the directory does not belong to the correct privileged system user.

I think the only way to fix this with the current OpenSSH is disabling strict mode, but normally I'm quite reluctant to do something like that.2


More information about the Cygwin mailing list