whole Cygwin release/ distribution issues

[Reini Urban]

Dave Korn schrieb:
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: cygwin-owner On Behalf Of David Christensen
>>Sent: 03 October 2004 03:15
>>Would you be interested in mentoring a willing volunteer?
>   Certainly.  Just stand still right here for just one minute........
>            ****KER-SQUELCH-SPLAT-SMACK****
> [sound of massive slap round face with a very wet kipper]
> <brushes dust off hands>  That'll learn 'im!

Wouldn't it be easy for the beginning to gather a list of
GTG (good-to-go) stable packages, without any known conflicts.

Or much better to gather a list of known conflicts, which have to be 
resolved/left out/added from/to this distro. The rest can be in then.
Don't know how to deal with mixed stable/test builds.
E.g. I assume all of gerrits new packages are with latest gcc / 
libtool-devel, which is still in test.

Maybe just start with issues for the binary packages:

Issues known to me so far:
ITP moratorium / SC (Steering Committee) idea?
   http://cygwin.com/ml/cygwin-apps/2004-03/msg00036.html
coreutils
   missing (required)
   http://cygwin.com/ml/cygwin-apps/2004-03/msg00150.html
apache
   missing (required)
apache-*php*
   missing (required)
mysql
   missing (required)
   at least "libmysql" and "mysql-client",
   "mysql-server" probably not needed.
gcc-core > 3.3.3
   needs libtool-devel-1.5.10 (still in test) for
     libtoolized packages: .rdata bug
postgreql-7.4.5
   pgperl fails
libmcrypt
   needs replacement (mingw build)
cygwin-1.5.11-1
   pipe bug
   cygserver on Win95 (already fixed?)
gnome2
   stable?
   some packages missing.
libcurl
   pending minor issues with wrong deps for libtool src builders.

convenience:
* cygcheck -f /usr/dict/words => none
* dllwrap docs: no man or info page,
     not even in the Cygwin/binutils*.README
* more init.d scripts for the services, maybe with
   additional service installers/uninstallers

Expected problems:
* freshly added gif support in libgd
* libungif pending and problematic X dependencies for libtool.
* sysbash package pending (to test service problems)
* ExplorerHere package pending (often requested feature)
* perl layout (better upgrade convenience)
* layout stuff:
   where to put optional or contrib binaries, not to pollute the path
   /usr/lib/<package>/bin/ probably
* xemacs 21.5 ?? (japanese need mule support)

Timeframe:
* wait for gnome2, apache, php and mysql or do without?
     php will need a lot of convenience extensions and dependent libs
* consider list of pending ITP's and not-GTG packages:
     graphviz, ploticus, libming, t1lib, Swarm,
     re2c, MTools, cdrtools, EMacro, leafnode, ac-archive,
     rxp, git, unrtf, lcab, ...
     all other of the ~100 Jaari ITP's probably not.
     (esp. when he is very busy now, and it was one year ago)

-- 
Reini Urban
http://xarch.tu-graz.ac.at/home/rurban/

--
Unsubscribe info:      http://cygwin.com/ml/#unsubscribe-simple
Problem reports:       http://cygwin.com/problems.html
Documentation:         http://cygwin.com/docs.html
FAQ:                   http://cygwin.com/faq/