[patch] stop objcopy breaking group sections

[Andrew Stubbs]

Hi,

objcopy (and strip -g) has a bug that breaks group sections. I've tested 
it using arm-none-eabi, but the problem almost certainly affects all 
targets.

To reproduce:

---test.cxx-------
class X
{
   public:
     int nokey() {return 0;}
};

int b(X*);
void t1()
{
   class X x;
   b(&x);
   x.nokey();
}
-----------------

$ arm-none-eabi-g++ -O0 -c test.cxx
$ arm-none-eabi-readelf -S -g -s test.o
...
   [ 1] .group            GROUP           00000000 000034 000010 04 
17  15  4
...
     15: 00000000    36 FUNC    WEAK   DEFAULT    6 _ZN1X5nokeyEv
...
COMDAT group section [    1] `.group' [_ZN1X5nokeyEv] contains 3 sections:

$ arm-none-eabi-objcopy test.o new.o
$ arm-none-eabi-readelf -S -g -s new.o
...
   [ 1] _ZN1X5nokeyEv     GROUP           00000000 000034 000010 04 
17  14  4
...
     14: 00000000     0 SECTION LOCAL  DEFAULT    1
...
COMDAT group section [    1] `_ZN1X5nokeyEv' [_ZN1X5nokeyEv] contains 3 
sections:

In each case I have shown the symbol indicated by the sh_info field. As 
you can see, it changes from 15 to 14, but the relevant symbol isn't in 
location 14 - it's still at 15. The section name has also been changed, 
but this is harmless, if undisirable. Unfortunately, the behaviour of 
readelf when sh_info doesn't make sense seems to somehow find the right 
value by chance, but the linker doesn't do the same. The new binary will 
no longer link correctly.

On closer investigation it turns out that the number 14 is "random" - 
that is, the algorithm gets it from totally the wrong place, although it 
has a predictable value.

In fact, it seems that code has been written to write sh_info, in the 
case of the assembler, read it, in the case of the linker, but the code 
to copy it is totally missing.

The attached patch should rectify this situation. I did also attempt to 
prevent it modifying the section name, but the linker is incapable of 
linking binaries where multiple sections have the same name (it only 
links in one of them), so I've given up on that.

OK?

Andrew Stubbs
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: group-strip.patch
Type: text/x-diff
Size: 1272 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://sourceware.org/pipermail/binutils/attachments/20080924/91cfb8f9/attachment.bin>