This is the mail archive of the
xconq7@sources.redhat.com
mailing list for the Xconq project.
Tweaking advances.g (was Re: New Windows Installer and Source Tarball)
- From: Eric McDonald <mcdonald at phy dot cmich dot edu>
- To: Jim Kingdon <kingdon at panix dot com>
- Cc: xconq7 at sources dot redhat dot com
- Date: Tue, 28 Sep 2004 14:24:25 -0400 (EDT)
- Subject: Tweaking advances.g (was Re: New Windows Installer and Source Tarball)
On Tue, 28 Sep 2004, Jim Kingdon wrote:
> Makes sense. I don't remember in what order I was in the habit of
> doing Joinery, but perhaps not at all (it appears to be a dead-end
> advance, since Horsemen are just as easy to get as Archers, and
> generally as good or better at combat).
I don't think much of Archers either. But anything that can
reasonably increase the number of deps required to get to
Elephants is probably a good thing, even if some of the units that
are enabled along the way are not effective.
> Joinery already depends on artisanry and carpentry. Barring a new set
> of construction advances, I don't really see anything else which fits
> the bill (it needs to be 4th generation, at least the way the rp
> values are set now, because 3rd or lower will be easy to get by the
> time one is thinking of going for Elephant, which is 5th generation).
Okay, thanks for looking.
> > Additionally, there is the animal training/guidance aspect; perhaps
> > some animal guidance skills (like a caravan) should be required.
>
> That would appear to be already covered; elephant depends on a whole
> line of animal advances (horse, donkey, camel, etc).
Yeah, I realized that was probably what those advances represented
after I wrote the above.
> Another thing to tweak is construction points. Right now the game
> board quickly gets overrun with units, and it is really tedious to
> move them all.
Agreed. However, implementing the ability to handle multiple unit
selections and to more handily set formations might largely
mitigate this tedium.
>There are some commented out values for construction
> points in advances.g which I thought were an improvement, but Hans
> didn't like the slow start to the game. The slow start could be
> speeded up by making a few early units cheaper (say, slingers and
> spearmen - I'd probably leave colonizers kind of expensive as they are
> the source of the exponential growth).
Currently the generations are pegged to a 2^n curve, IIRC. Perhaps
we need to make the curve more of a slanted s-shape so that the
last few generations don't take forever to research. I say this,
because there is a limit on city densities (due to their
increasing size and reach into the terrain), and so one cannot
continue to settle new cities at a pace that keeps up with the
growth of research costs. This is especially true if two sides
are the last ones remaining and in a deadlock situation.
> We shouldn't go too far overboard on elephants; since Elephant is a
> dead-end advance, it does make sense for the units to be kind of
> powerful.
Agreed. My intention is not to tune the Elephants into oblivion.
They are, and by all rights should be, a powerful unit.
>Making the player choose between Elephant now (for
> short-term gains) or setting themself up for Phalanx some turns from
> now is an interesting trade-off situation.
I have found that, in practice, I can wipe the board with
Elephants before I can even finish researching Phalanxes (let
alone Legiones).
It would be nice to make Elephants (immediate gratification)
versus Phalanxes (serious firepower, but later) more of a
tradeoff.
>I suppose if we really
> wanted to take this to an extreme, we wouldn't seek to have Elephant
> depend on existing advances like artisanry, but instead to have its
> own set, which don't mix with the advances which take you towards
> Phalanx.
That's a thought. If you have a specific proposal, I am all
ears.... (Or just check it in, and if I like it, I will adopt it
for my branch of the sources.)
Eric