This is the mail archive of the cygwin-patches mailing list for the Cygwin project.

Index Nav: [Date Index] [Subject Index] [Author Index] [Thread Index]
Message Nav: [Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]
Other format: [Raw text]

Patch to optionally disable overlapped pipes


As I have recently mentioned on the main Cygwin mailing list, Cygwin by
default creates FILE_FLAG_OVERLAPPED named pipes for the standard file
handles (stdin/stdout/stderr).  These overlapped pipes require all programs
using ReadFile/WriteFile to use overlapped I/O when using the pipes.  Since
standard runtimes in Win32 programs don't normally use overlapped I/O on the
standard file handles, most Win32 programs will exhibit undefined behavior
when called by Cygwin.  In my case, it has resulted in a problem with
calling .NET Framework 4.0 programs from Cygwin (which, coincidentally,
NETFX 4.0 also probably has a bug resulting in undefined behavior that
definitely clashes with overlapped pipes).

The attached patch creates a new "pipe_nooverlap" flag in the CYGWIN
environment variable (similar to the existing pipe_byte flag).  By default,
the flag would not be set and Cygwin will continue to make overlapped pipes
by default, because I did not know if this will result in any breakages
elsewhere in some Cygwin packages.

If the new "pipe_nooverlap" flag is set, then Cygwin won't make overlapped
pipes by default (i.e. pipes made by the pipe or pipe2 functions).  For me,
this got NETFX 4.0 programs working again.  I've been using it all day today
with no ill effects noted.  It seems safe to use.  But I made it a flag
because I am not 100% certain that some package won't break, and it isn't
needed if you are only running Cygwin programs (which presumably use
Cygwin1.dll which presumably is using overlapped I/O everywhere).

If the maintainers feel that a CYGWIN flag isn't necessary and it is safe to
always remove FILE_FLAG_OVERLAPPED, then I can submit a patch that doesn't
have the "pipe_nooverlap" flag - i.e. just assumes the flag is always set.

Thank you for the consideration of this patch.  Here are the change log

2013-12-24  James Johnston  <>

	* (struct parse_thing): Add "pipe_nooverlap" option.
	* (pipe_nooverlap): Declare.
	* (fhandler_pipe::create): Honor pipe_nooverlap to create
	overlapped pipes if set.

==== Documentation changelog entry ====

2013-12-24  James Johnston  <>

	* cygwinenv.xml: Add pipe_nooverlap description.

Best regards,

James Johnston

Attachment: pipepatch
Description: Binary data

Index Nav: [Date Index] [Subject Index] [Author Index] [Thread Index]
Message Nav: [Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]